Philadelphia, PA - The classic Reuben is an American grilled sandwich packed with corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, with Russian dressing, between slices of rye bread. We have you covered with the be Reuben sandwich spots from neighborhood pubs to casual daytime lunch spots in Philly.
Philly's Reuben Quest: Top Spots for the Ultimate Corned Beef Classic
While the cheesesteak reigns supreme in many Philly food debates, the city's rich deli culture means it also excels at another iconic sandwich: the Reuben. This perfect combination of corned beef, tangy sauerkraut, melted Swiss cheese, and creamy Russian dressing, all grilled between slices of rye bread, is a masterpiece when done right. If you're searching for the best Reuben sandwich in the Philadelphia area, here are some essential destinations known for doing this classic justice.
Top Spots for a Terrific Reuben:
-
Famous 4th Street Delicatessen (Queen Village)
- Why Visit: A true Philadelphia institution, this Jewish deli serves nostalgia alongside famously huge portions. Their classic Reuben is piled high with quality corned beef and all the traditional fixings, embodying the old-school deli experience. The historic atmosphere with walls covered in photos adds to the charm.
- Location: 700 S 4th St, Philadelphia, PA 19147
-
Hershel's East Side Deli (Reading Terminal Market)
- Why Visit: Located within the bustling Reading Terminal Market, Hershel's consistently tops lists for the best Reuben (and pastrami) in the city. They are known for their expertly hand-carved, melt-in-your-mouth corned beef, perfectly balanced ingredients, and expertly grilled rye bread. Prepare for a potential line, but it's worth the wait.
- Location: 51 N 12th St (Reading Terminal Market), Philadelphia, PA 19107
-
Schlesinger's Delicatessen (Center City West)
- Why Visit: Another top-tier Jewish deli, Schlesinger's delivers an authentic deli experience in Center City. Their Reuben is highly regarded, featuring quality corned beef, tangy sauerkraut, and the perfect cheese melt on well-grilled rye. It's a go-to for a classic, satisfying deli sandwich.
- Location: 1521 Locust St, Philadelphia, PA 19102
-
Hymie's (Merion Station)
- Why Visit: Just outside the city on the Main Line, Hymie's is a legendary suburban Jewish deli destination. Expect hefty sandwiches overflowing with meat. Their Reuben is a classic execution done right, and the experience is enhanced by their famous self-serve pickle bar.
- Location: 342 Montgomery Ave, Merion Station, PA 19066
-
Middle Child (Wash West)
- Why Visit: While known for its modern, creative takes on diner and deli classics, Middle Child executes fundamentals extremely well. They often feature house-made corned beef specials, and their skill with sandwich construction means any Reuben or Reuben-inspired special they offer is likely to be exceptional, served in a cool, casual setting.
- Location: 248 S 11th St, Philadelphia, PA 19107
-
Bud and Marilyn's (Midtown Village/Wash West)
- Why Visit: This spot offers American classics in a fun, retro-inspired setting. While not strictly a deli, they serve a well-regarded Reuben sandwich that fits perfectly with their upscale comfort food menu, providing a great option if you're looking for a Reuben alongside other American fare and cocktails.
- Location: 1234 Locust St, Philadelphia, PA 19107
What Makes a Great Philly Reuben?
It's all about balance: tender, flavorful corned beef (not too lean!), tangy but not overpowering sauerkraut, perfectly melted Swiss cheese, the right amount of zesty Russian or Thousand Island dressing, and crucially, well-buttered and grilled rye bread that holds everything together without getting soggy.
Philadelphia's deli scene ensures that the quest for a perfect Reuben sandwich is just as rewarding as the hunt for the best cheesesteak. From historic Jewish delis piling meat high on rye to modern spots putting their spin on the corned beef classic, the city and its suburbs offer fantastic options. Visit these top contenders to experience some of the best Reubens Philadelphia has to offer!
