NEW JERSEY - For over two decades, if you wanted the ultimate nostalgic dining experience in South Jersey, you went to The Pop Shop. Located in the heart of downtown Collingswood, this 1950s-style soda fountain was famous for its bubblegum-colored booths, towering milkshakes, and an award-winning menu featuring over 30 varieties of grilled cheese. It was such a beloved destination that its signature sandwich even famously challenged a celebrity chef on the Food Network’s Throwdown with Bobby Flay.
However, if you are planning a trip to 729 Haddon Avenue in 2026 to grab a classic melt, you are in for a surprise. The Pop Shop permanently closed its doors in mid-2025.
As the editorial team for PhillyBite Magazine and WherePhilly, we track the region's culinary shifts. Here is what you need to know about the closure, what has taken over the space, and where you can go to satisfy your gourmet grilled cheese cravings in South Jersey today.
The Legacy of The Pop Shop
The Pop Shop was a true Collingswood institution. It built a massive regional following by serving up quirky twists on classic American comfort food in a highly energetic, family-friendly atmosphere. Their grilled cheese menu was legendary—particularly "The Calvert," a decadent melt of Monterey Jack cheese, roasted turkey, applewood bacon, and fresh avocado. While its departure marks the end of a long chapter for downtown Collingswood, the vibrant Haddon Avenue dining scene continues to evolve.
What is at 729 Haddon Avenue Now?
Following the retirement of The Pop Shop concept, the massive corner space at 729 Haddon Avenue has been completely transformed.
Today, the location is home to Jersey Kebab, an excellent, highly-rated eatery specializing in authentic Turkish and Mediterranean street food. If you visit the space now, you can expect phenomenal charcoal-grilled Chicken Shish Kebabs, savory Beef-Lamb Gyros, fresh falafel wraps, and homemade hummus rather than burgers and fries.
Where to Find the Best Grilled Cheese in South Jersey (2026 Picks)
Just because The Pop Shop is gone does not mean your cravings have to go unsatisfied. Here are two standout local spots serving up incredible, gourmet melts in the region right now:
1. Maria's Bread Sandwiches (Collingswood, NJ)
You do not even have to leave Collingswood to find an elite grilled cheese. Located just down the street at 685 Haddon Avenue, Maria's Bread Sandwiches is crafting some of the most elevated, artisanal melts in the state.
-
The Must-Try: Order "The Hannah"—a spectacular, sweet-and-savory combination of creamy Brie cheese, millionaire bacon, and homemade apple butter, all perfectly grilled on fresh sourdough.
2. Ma's Cafe (Point Pleasant Beach, NJ)
If you are willing to take a drive toward the Jersey Shore, Ma's Cafe is currently making waves as one of the best new spots for comfort food. Family-owned and known for massive portions, they take the simple sandwich to the next level using thick-cut artisan bread.
-
The Must-Try: Their hearty Short Rib Grilled Cheese takes two massive slices of bread and loads them with a heavy melt of premium cheese and tender, slow-cooked meats.
Share This Article on Social Media
Joy Franklin
Food and Event Writer
My joy is aimed at food and foodie lovers. I enjoy covering trends, issues, and all things Philly.
