Top Five Restaurants for Fine Dining in Cape May NJ

A Taste of Elegance: A Modern Guide to Fine Dining in Cape May, NJ

Cape May, New Jersey, is celebrated for its stunning Victorian architecture and beautiful beaches, but it has also firmly established itself as a premier destination for fine dining. The town's culinary scene is a sophisticated blend of historic charm and modern culinary innovation, with a focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients, particularly from the sea. While beloved classics endure, the scene is always evolving. Here is an updated guide to five of the top restaurants that define the elegant and delicious world of fine dining in Cape May.

1. The Washington Inn

• The Vibe: Set in a beautiful 1840 former plantation house, The Washington Inn is the epitome of classic Cape May elegance. With its various intimate dining rooms, cozy fireside nooks, and a beautiful outdoor patio, the atmosphere is perfect for a romantic dinner or special occasion. The service is famously warm and professional.
• The Cuisine: The menu is a celebration of inventive American cuisine with a French influence. Under the guidance of Executive Chef Vincent Celeste, the kitchen creates beautifully composed dishes that are both refined and deeply flavorful. Their extensive, award-winning wine list is one of the best in the state, making wine pairings an essential part of the experience.
• Location: 801 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204

2. Sapore Italiano

• The Vibe: Housed in a stately Victorian home in West Cape May, Sapore Italiano offers a charming and romantic atmosphere. It's an intimate and popular spot, known for its authentic, high-quality Italian cuisine and attentive service. As a BYOB, it's a favorite for those who wish to bring a special bottle of wine.
• The Cuisine: Chef Rimi focuses on classic Italian dishes made with fresh, local ingredients. The menu features an excellent selection of homemade pastas, including many gluten-free options, alongside expertly prepared veal, chicken, and seafood dishes. Don't miss their homemade gnocchi or the branzino special when available.
• Location: 416 S Broadway, West Cape May, NJ 08204

3. The Lobster House

• The Vibe: A true Cape May icon, The Lobster House is a sprawling waterfront complex on Fisherman's Wharf that offers a complete and authentic seafood experience. While it has several casual dining options, the main dining room provides a classic, nautical-themed fine dining atmosphere with panoramic views of Cape May Harbor.
• The Cuisine: This is the ultimate destination for fresh, straightforward seafood. With its own commercial fishing fleet, the restaurant serves fish that is truly "boat-to-table." While the entire menu is extensive, their specialty is, of course, fresh lobster, along with local scallops and classic seafood platters. For a pre-dinner drink, grabbing a cocktail on the moored Schooner American is a can't-miss experience.
• Location: 906 Schellengers Landing Rd, Cape May, NJ 08204

4. George's Place (Multiple Locations)

• The Vibe: A beloved Cape May institution, George's Place has expanded its footprint while maintaining its reputation for fantastic Greek-inspired cuisine. While their original corner spot has transformed into a new concept, their beachfront location on Beach Avenue offers a more upscale, taverna-style experience in the evenings with stunning ocean views.
• The Cuisine: Expect fresh and vibrant Greek and Mediterranean flavors. The menu is packed with classics like grilled octopus, lamb chops, and fresh whole fish, all prepared with an authentic touch. It remains a cash-only and BYOB establishment, so be sure to plan accordingly.
• Location (Beachfront): 301 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204

5. Hemingway's Steaks & Seafood

• The Vibe: Located within the Grand Hotel, Hemingway's offers a "classically casual" fine dining experience with ocean views. While it has a relaxed and sometimes lively bar area with TVs for sports, the dining room provides a more traditional setting perfect for enjoying a classic steak and seafood dinner.
• The Cuisine: The menu focuses on contemporary American classics. They are known for their high-quality, hand-cut steaks, fresh, locally sourced seafood, and popular specials like their Wednesday Prime Rib Night. The "Sunset Dining" menu is an excellent option for enjoying a delicious meal with a beautiful view at a great value.
• Location: 1045 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204

Share This Article on Social Media