5 Best Pizza Shops in Cape May New Jersey

5 Best Pizza Shops in Cape May New Jersey

Photo: Lucky Bones Back Water Grille

Guide
Typography
  • Smaller Small Medium Big Bigger
  • Default Helvetica Segoe Georgia Times

Philadelphia, PABest Cape May, NJ Pizza —Cape May, NJ, is known for its many cute breakfasts and dockside restaurants. But did you know that it's also getting known for its Italian cuisine? For example, Mario's Pizza and Italian Eatery, which serves New York-style pies, and Panico's Bistro brick-oven pizza served out of an old church building. Below, our staff has created our favorite spots for The Best Pizza in Cape May County.


Cape May's Pizza Perfection: A Slice of Seaside Bliss


Cape May, New Jersey, a charming seaside town known for its Victorian architecture and pristine beaches, boasts a hidden treasure: a thriving pizza scene. Whether you are craving a classic Margherita after sunbathing or seeking a gourmet pie to complement your evening stroll, Cape May's pizzerias offer a slice of heaven for every taste. Here's your guide to some of the town's most noteworthy destinations for pizza perfection:

1. Lucky Bones Back Water Grille: Brick Oven Bliss

This family-friendly, laid-back eatery serves up more than just ing ocean views. Lucky Bones Back Water Grille boasts a brick oven that churns out some of the best pizzas in Cape May. Their thin-crust Margherita pizza is a must-try, showcasing the simple perfection of fresh ingredients and a perfectly charred crust. For enthusiasts, their extensive craft beer list offers the ideal pairing for your pizza feast.

2. Jake's Pizza Company: Homemade with Heart

Jake's Pizza Company is a testament to the power of fresh ingredients and homemade goodness. Their dough and sauce are made fresh daily, ensuring a flavorful foundation for their delicious pizzas. With a focus on quality and a commitment to crafting delicious pies, Jake's Pizza Company is a must-visit for pizza purists.

3. Panico's Bistro: Italian Flair in a Historic Setting

Housed in a beautifully converted old church building, Panico's Bistro exudes charm and culinary excellence. Their brick oven pizzas are a highlight, showcasing classic Italian flavors with a touch of Mediterranean influence. Panico's also offers a delectable menu of Italian fare and a renowned Sunday Dinner, making it a perfect spot for a family gathering or a romantic evening. Don't forget, it's BYOB, so bring your favorite bottle of wine to complement your meal.



4. Mario's Pizza and Italian Eatery: A Family Affair

Mario's Pizza and Italian Eatery is a family-run gem serving delicious pizzas, sandwiches, and Italian entrees in a casual counter-serve setting. Their pizzas, made from scratch with fresh ingredients and just the right amount of toppings, are available with original and stuffed crusts. Whether grabbing a quick slice or enjoying a leisurely meal, Mario's is a must-try for pizza lovers in Cape May.

5. Roman's Pizza House: Thin-Crust Perfection

Roman's Pizza House is a haven for those who appreciate the art of a perfectly crafted thin-crust pizza. Their signature pies boast a crispy crust, topped with a sweet sauce studded with chunks of fresh tomatoes. This no-frills pizzeria is a local favorite, offering a delicious and affordable quick lunch or casual dinner option.



Beyond the Slice:

This list is a starting point for exploring Cape May's vibrant pizza scene. With numerous pizzerias scattered throughout the town, there's a perfect pie waiting to be discovered for every palate and preference. So, whether you're seeking a classic Margherita, a gourmet creation, or a simple slice of cheesy goodness, embark on a pizza pilgrimage in Cape May and savor the flavors of this seaside paradise.


Social Media PhillyShare This Article on Social Media

plate

Written By: Philly Bite Magazines Staff

 The Best Of Series consists of a round-up of the best places in Philly to find great food, entertainment, and more.

Best Cape May, New Jersey Pizza Restaurants


 

Latest Posts

Sign up via our free email subscription service to receive notifications when new information is available.

Sponsered Ads



Follow PhillyBite:

Follow Our Socials Below