Philadelphia, PA
- Chocolate and vanilla lovers might be shocked when they see that the strawberry milkshake is the most popular milkshake across the country. The creamy blend of strawberries and ice cream was the number one milkshake in 10 U.S. states. States like California, Illinois, and Louisiana are a few of the places that have strawberry milkshake fanatics.
The Most Popular Milkshake Flavors in Every State: From Chocolate to… Pineapple?
When it comes to dessert, Americans are loyal to their frozen treats. A recent look at data across the U.S. reveals that neither freezing temperatures nor regional borders can stop people from enjoying a cold, creamy milkshake.
While some classics reign supreme, other states have surprisingly specific—and fruity—preferences. Here is a breakdown of the most popular milkshake flavors across the country.
The Undisputed King: Chocolate
It turns out you just can't beat the classics. Despite the endless variety of new toppings and mix-ins available today, Chocolate remains the number one choice for Americans.
A total of eight states selected Chocolate as their superior flavor. Interestingly, the cold weather doesn't seem to deter the craving; residents in northern states like Michigan, Maine, and Indiana listed Chocolate as their top pick, proving that a rich cocoa shake is a year-round staple regardless of the forecast.
The Big Surprise: Pineapple
Perhaps the most shocking twist in the data comes from two massive states with very different vibes. Both New York and Texas bucked the traditional trends, naming Pineapple as their favorite milkshake flavor.
Whether it's a tropical escape in a cup or a preference for a tangy, fruit-forward treat, the "Aloha" spirit is clearly alive and well in both the Big Apple and the Lone Star State.
The Modern Classic: Oreo
Coming in third among the most popular flavors in the country is the Oreo Milkshake.
The cookies-and-cream combination has solidified itself as a modern staple, with six states choosing it as their number one. The blend of vanilla ice cream and crunchy cookie bits offers a texture that simple syrup-based shakes just can't match.
The Seasonal Sensation: The Shamrock Shake
Breaking into the top five is a flavor that isn't even available year-round: The Shamrock Shake.
This iconic, minty-green drink typically appears only around St. Patrick's Day, but its limited-time availability seems to fuel the obsession. The scarcity marketing works—people love the superb mint flavor and the rush to "get it while it lasts," propelling it past many year-round flavors in popularity.
The Best of the Rest
Beyond the top contenders, American taste buds are incredibly diverse. Several other unique flavors made the list of state favorites, showcasing regional preferences for specific ingredients:
- Nutella: For the hazelnut and chocolate lovers.
- Peanut Butter: A savory-sweet favorite.
- Peach: A fruity alternative to strawberry.
- Peppermint: A refreshing, superb choice often associated with the holidays.
