Pennsylvania—Pike County is just a stone's throw from the New York State Line, and some of that proximity shows in the county's many pizza shops, which serve authentic NY-style pizza.
From a small-town NY-style pizza made with fresh ingredients at Good Time Pizza in Dingmans Ferry to one of Pike County's best pizzas with a view at Jimmy's Lakeside Pizza. We have you covered with our staff picks of the Best of Pike County Pizza and Pizzeria's
Best of Pike County Pennsylvania Pizza Shops and Restaurants
1. Jimmy's Lakeside Pizza
Jimmy's on the Lake has one of Pike County's best pizzas, and the rest of the food is also excellent. But this place is one of our favorites because of its friendly and tentative staff. This is a great pizza shop and atmosphere to sit back and relax with some great pizza and hay they also deliver. 106 Log Tavern Way, Milford, PA
2. John's of Arthur Avenue
John's is in a charming old building with a warm, cozy fireplace, offering a casual atmosphere. John's is an excellent BYOB offering one of Pike's best pizzas, with a delicious and crunchy mouth-watering crust. There, Graffiti pizza is a must-try. It is a great place to eat, with excellent food and a wonderful outdoor seating area. 115 7th St, Milford, PA
3. Carini Cucina & Pizzeria
Carini Cucina & Pizzeria offers one of the county's best pies with that N.Y. taste, with the perfect thin crust and great sauce. Carini is a small pizzeria with a friendly and attentive staff. The workers behind the counter were charming, and the pizza was a kind of authentic N.Y.-style pie with a very crispy crust.203 6th St, Milford, PA
4. Good Time Pizza
Good Time is a small-town NY-style pizza made with fresh ingredients and served in very generous portions. We love this little pizza shop; the only turn-off is that they don't accept credit cards, sorry—cash only. Friendly people, great pie, and one of our favorite crusts. 1820 PA-739, Dingmans Ferry, PA
5. Franico's Pizzeria & Trattoria
This genuine 18-inch Grandma Pie is one of the best around and truly has an excellent flavor, cheese, great crust, and a subtly sweet sauce yet, ideally, zesty. They also have ice-cold beers on tap. You can't go wrong here. 302 Pennsylvania Ave, Matamoras, PA
Share Pike County Pizza on Social Media
Written By: Philly Bite Magazines Staff
Pennsylvania's Best Of Series consists of a round-up of the best places in the PA area to find great food, entertainment, and more to Find Pike Counties Best Pizza Shops