6 Must-Try: Best Ice Cream In Cape May, NJ

Cooling Down in Cape May: A Guide to the Best Ice Cream Shops

Cape May, New Jersey, is the quintessential charming seaside town, known for its stunning Victorian architecture and beautiful beaches. When the summer sun is shining, there is no better way to cool down than with a refreshing scoop of ice cream. The town is a paradise for those with a sweet tooth, offering everything from iconic frozen custard and authentic Italian gelato to unique ice cream sandwiches. Here is a guide to six of the best ice cream shops in Cape May that are perfect for creating sweet summer memories.

1. Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard

• The Scoop: A true Jersey Shore legend, Kohr Brothers is a must-visit for its famously smooth and creamy frozen custard. With multiple locations, including one right on the beachfront promenade, it's a convenient and consistently delicious treat.
• Don't Miss: The iconic orange and vanilla twist cone. It's a refreshing and nostalgic flavor combination that generations of beachgoers have loved.
• Vibe: Classic, quick-service boardwalk treat.

2. Peace Pie

• The Scoop: For a truly unique and innovative ice cream experience, head to Peace Pie. This popular spot specializes in gourmet ice cream sandwiches unlike any other. They feature a generous layer of ice cream and a layer of pie filling (like cherry pie or key lime pie) sandwiched between two freshly baked cookies.
• Don't Miss: Experimenting with their creative and rotating flavor combinations, from classic chocolate chip cookie dough to more adventurous options. It's a decadent and unforgettable creation.
• Vibe: Unique, creative, and perfect for an indulgent treat.

3. Cione Gelato

• The Scoop: Experience the authentic taste of Italy right in Cape May at Cione Gelato. They serve old-world style gelato, which is richer, denser, and often more intensely flavored than American ice cream, all made with fresh ingredients using traditional techniques.
• Don't Miss: Classic Italian flavors like pistachio and stracciatella, alongside a variety of seasonal fruit sorbets. Their friendly staff is always happy to offer a sample to help you find the perfect scoop.
• Vibe: Authentic, artisanal Italian gelateria.

4. Dry Dock Ice Cream Bar

• The Scoop: Tucked away near Cape May Harbor, the Dry Dock is a beloved spot for both a casual meal and a sweet treat. While they serve classic American fare, their extensive ice cream selection is a major draw, featuring cones, sundaes, floats, milkshakes, and even malted shakes.
• Don't Miss: Trying one of their unique, homemade hard ice cream flavors. They are also dog-friendly and offer "pup cups" for your furry friends!
• Vibe: A casual, relaxed hidden gem away from the main beach crowds.

5. Margie's Big Top

• The Scoop: A vibrant and colorful fixture on the Washington Street Mall, Margie's Big Top offers a classic, family-friendly ice cream parlor experience. They serve a wide variety of hand-dipped ice cream flavors, sundaes, and other sweet treats.
• Don't Miss: Soaking in the fun, circus-themed decor while enjoying a classic cone or sundae. It's a perfect stop while strolling and shopping downtown.
• Vibe: Fun, nostalgic, and family-oriented.

6. Uncle Charley's Ice Cream

• The Scoop: A long-standing local favorite, Uncle Charley's is known for serving high-quality, delicious homemade ice cream. This is a classic parlor that focuses on getting the flavors just right, from rich chocolate to creamy vanilla and fresh fruit options.
• Don't Miss: Trying one of their seasonal specialties or creating your own custom sundae.
• Vibe: A beloved, traditional neighborhood ice cream shop.

Share Cape May NJ, Ice Cream on Social Media