CAPE MAY, NJ - One can't hit the Jersey Beaches without grabbing some Ice Cream; in Cape May, you have many options to grab a scoop. From Old-Fashion Ice Cream Parlors to Counter service shops, below are a few of our staff's favorite Ice Cream Spots in Cape May
6 Must-Visit Ice Cream Shops for a Sweet Escape
Cape May, New Jersey, is a charming seaside town known for its Victorian architecture, beautiful beaches, and delectable dining scene. When the sun is shining, and the temperatures rise, nothing beats cooling down with a refreshing scoop of ice cream or a frosty frozen treat. Here are six of the best ice cream shops in Cape May to satisfy your sweet tooth and create lasting summer memories.
1. King's Ice Cream
This combination of ice cream shop and toy store is a fun and unique family destination. Kids can browse the toy selection while enjoying their favorite ice cream flavors, making it a perfect stop for a sweet treat and a little fun.
Tip: Check out their selection of vintage toys and games for a nostalgic trip down memory lane.
2. Fine Fellows Creamery
Located in the heart of Cape May, this local institution is a favorite among locals and tourists. They serve creamy scoops from Bassett's of Philadelphia, a renowned ice cream brand known for its quality and flavor. With friendly service and affordable prices, Fine Fellows Creamery is the perfect spot to enjoy a classic ice cream cone on a warm summer day.
Try their signature "Fine Fellows Fudge," a decadent blend of chocolate ice cream and fudge pieces.
3. Peace Pie
For a unique and innovative ice cream experience, head to Peace Pie. This popular spot specializes in ice cream sandwiches, but not your ordinary kind. They offer a variety of creative flavor combinations, from classic chocolate chip cookie dough to more adventurous options like lavender honey and salted caramel pretzels.
Tip: Don't be afraid to experiment with different flavors and create your own custom ice cream sandwich.
4. Cione Gelato
Experience the authentic taste of Italian gelato at Cione Gelato. Their old-world style gelato, made with fresh ingredients and traditional techniques, is rich, creamy, and flavorful. With a wide variety of options to choose from, including classic flavors like pistachio and stracciatella, as well as seasonal specialties, Cione Gelato is a must-visit for any gelato lover.
Tip: Ask for a sample before you decide on your flavor. Their friendly staff is always happy to help you find the perfect scoop.
5. Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard
A beloved institution with multiple locations in Cape May, Kohr Brothers is famous for its creamy frozen custard. Whether you prefer a simple cone or a decadent sundae with all the toppings, Kohr's delivers a consistently delicious and satisfying treat.
Try their classic orange-vanilla twist, a refreshing and iconic flavor combination.
6. Dry Dock Ice Cream Bar & Grill
This low-key spot is a hidden gem for those seeking a casual meal and a sweet treat. Their menu features American staples like seafood plates and burgers, but their extensive ice cream selection sets them apart. Choose from cones, sundaes, floats, milkshakes, and even malted shakes. They even offer pup cups for your furry friends!
Tip: If you're feeling adventurous, try one of their unique ice cream flavors, like "Monkey Business" or "Blueberry Pancake."
Whether strolling along the beach, exploring the historic district, or simply seeking a sweet escape, Cape May's ice cream shops offer a delightful array of frozen treats to satisfy your cravings. So, indulge in a scoop (or two) and experience the incredible, creamy flavors that make Cape May a summer paradise.
