The Complete Guide to Restaurants in Cape May

Jersey Shore
  • Smaller Small Medium Big Bigger
  • Default Helvetica Segoe Georgia Times

Restaurants in Cape MayPhiladelphia, PA - During your stay in Cape May, make a point of eating at the various fine dining restaurants. The following are some of our top recommendations: Lucky Bones Back Water Grille, The Blue Pig Tavern, Tisha's Fine Dining, and The Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar. Read on to discover more about these restaurants.

Top 25 Best Restaurants in Cape May

1. Lucky Bones Back Water Grille

Located on the waterfront, the casual yet upscale Lucky Bones Backwater Grille blends three distinct atmospheres: an open brick oven pizzeria on the bay, a bright dining room with romantic lighting, and a rectangular bar. Despite its casual atmosphere, it still manages to draw a lively crowd. Happy Hour is available, and it is easy to stay late after dinner. You can also enjoy a drink at the bar with your meal. 1200 NJ-109, Cape May, NJ 08204

2. The Blue Pig Tavern

The Blue Pig Tavern in Cape May is part of the famous Congress Hall Hotel. It's known for its classic American fare and a menu based on seasonal ingredients. Freshly caught seafood and local produce are the stars of the menu, and a grilled Berkshire pig from Beach Plum Farm is used in the cooking. The restaurant has a long menu, and it's worth perusing it to find something you love. 200 Congress Pl, Cape May, NJ 08204

3. Tisha's Fine Dining

Tisha's Fine Dining is located in the historic section of Cape May, New Jersey. This cozy sit-down restaurant specializes in New American fare, including sandwiches and burgers. The ambiance is charming and offers an excellent view of the waterfront. Lunch is also available in the lovely dining room. For a quick bite, try the daily specials and takeout specials. During the week, the menu features specials every day, including a weekend brunch. 322 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204

4. Peter Shields Inn

The Peter Shields Inn is one of Cape May's most beloved spots in the historic Peter Shields Mansion. This quaint eatery serves American dishes in an upscale setting with a fun and laid-back vibe. It's located in a 1907 mansion and has a friendly and lively atmosphere for diners to enjoy. Known for its small plates and burgers, the Peter Shields Inn serves a variety of American fare in a cozy setting. 1301 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204

5. Aleathea's Restaurant

You can dine in the elegant waterfront setting of this upscale eatery in Cape May, New Jersey. The Victorian Inn serves upscale American cuisine. Guests can enjoy a cocktail at the bar or an elegant meal in the dining room. Alethea's restaurant offers a great view of the harbor on the Cape May waterfront. Book a table in this restaurant to taste Cape May's history and current happenings. 7 Ocean St, Cape May, NJ 08204

6. 410 Bank Street Restaurant

410 Bank St has been around for fifteen years and continues to excel under new management and long-term staff. They take pride in their service, which has been a problem in many Cape May restaurants. Despite staffing shortages, 410 Bank St. continues to improve its service. Read on for some of the restaurant's key improvements. After 15 years, this restaurant receives rave reviews from locals and tourists alike. 410 Bank St, Cape May, NJ 08204

7. Black Duck On Sunset

The Black Duck on Sunset restaurant in Cape May, New Jersey, serves various breakfast and lunch items. The food is moderately priced, and many customers comment on the quality of their coffee. The restaurant also hosts catered events, private parties, and rehearsal dinners. Its 4.6 Google rating indicates that this restaurant has high customer satisfaction, and the staff is very attentive and friendly. 1 Sunset Blvd, West Cape May, NJ 08204

8. Louisa's Cafe

The long-standing Louisa's Café in Cape May, New Jersey, espoused the farm-to-table philosophy even before the mainstream concept in America. Its yellow building is a charming dining room where the local and regional fare is prepared with a focus on fresh, high-quality ingredients. Fresh fish and produce are served alongside dishes that are expertly seasoned. Its owners were longtime Cape May residents who enjoyed dining at the café. 104 Jackson St, Cape May, NJ 08204

9. Viggiano's on Sunset

If you're looking for an authentic Italian restaurant, look no further than Viggiano's on Sunset. The restaurant on Sunset Boulevard, across from Exit Zero Filling Station, offers pizza and pasta. This Cape May, New Jersey, is an Italian restaurant that opened in the summer of 2019. It was recently named one of the state's 30 best new restaurants by the New Jersey Monthly. Mark Viggiano, the son of first-generation Italians, owns the restaurant. 109 Sunset Blvd, West Cape May, NJ 08204

10. The Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar

The Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar in historic downtown Cape May is a humming breakfast-to-dinner restaurant featuring American cuisine. Live music and an open bar make for a fun atmosphere. You can listen to live music and dance the night away! The atmosphere is relaxed, and the staff is amiable. Guests are encouraged to bring family and friends. Check out the weekend jazz night for a fun night out and enjoy some live music. 19 Jackson St, Cape May, NJ 08204

11. The Pier House

With a casual, beach-chic ambiance, the Pier House is the perfect place to enjoy a meal while admiring the stunning ocean views. White stone bar tops, blue-and-white tiled floors, and accents of blue hue complement the casual ambiance of the restaurant. A talented culinary team serves mouth-watering meals made with local, seasonal ingredients. The restaurant is sure to please your taste buds and is open daily for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. 1317 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204

12. Washington Inn & Wine Bar

The Washington Inn specializes in fine dining, with six separate dining areas, including an outdoor patio, a cozy fireside nook, and indoor and outdoor seating. You can dine al fresco during the summer, enjoy a cocktail in one of the four dining rooms, or both. Whether you're dining al fresco on the summer patio or cozying up by the fireside, there's no shortage of delicious options. The Washington Inn was built in 1840; since then, it has been a class by itself. Its executive chef, Mimi Wood, has been a mainstay for almost a decade. 801 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204

13. George's Place

You must visit George's Place in Cape May, NJ if you're craving Greek food. This small corner restaurant is famous for its fresh Greek cuisine. It offers a variety of menu options to choose from. During the day, the restaurant looks like a diner, but it transforms into a lively Greek tavern when the sun sets. "Opa!" is the traditional Greek greeting, so you can enjoy a delicious meal while watching the sunset over the Atlantic Ocean. 801 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204

14. Hemingway's Steaks & Seafood

Hemingway's Steaks and Seafood is one of Cape May's most popular casual dining establishments. The restaurant specializes in contemporary American cuisine, featuring locally sourced seafood and juicy steaks. A special "Sunset Dining" menu lets guests enjoy the restaurant's ocean view while enjoying a specialty cocktail. The restaurant is in the Grand Hotel and features a cozy atmosphere and TVs with sports. In The Grand Hotel, 1045 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ

15. Sapore Italiano

Located in a stately Victorian home in West Cape May, New Jersey, Sapore Italiano serves Italian-inspired cuisine. Chef Rimi sources local ingredients for his menu, and many pasta dishes are gluten-free. The menu features classic Italian dishes like spaghetti and gnocchi Pomodoro; many portions are gluten-free. It is a great place to host a family dinner and enjoy a delicious meal. 416 S Broadway, West Cape May, NJ 08204

16. The Lobster House

The Lobster House is on Fisherman's Wharf in Cape May, NJ. Located in a former fishing village, this restaurant is a favorite among locals and visitors. The restaurant is a popular destination for seafood lovers and is open all year round. Lunch and dinner are available at the restaurant. Still, you can also order takeout and cocktails to enjoy on the deck of the historic Schooner American. 906 Schellengers Landing Rd, Cape May, NJ 08204

17. Vintage BYOB 

If you want a unique dining experience in Cape May, NJ, you will want to check out Vintage BYOB. Located on the Emlen Physick Estate, this casual dining spot offers a unique menu for a diverse crowd. The restaurant's cuisine can be described as "wild." In addition to the relaxed dining vibe, the menu offers creative dishes with a twist. There is patio seating and an outdoor seating area. 1048 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204

18. Iccara Italian Bistro

This cozy Sicilian eatery offers seafood specialties, steaks, and kid's fare. The early bird special is also a popular attraction. If you are looking for an evening out with friends, Iccara's BYOB policy is a great option. If you have a favorite wine, bring it with you. 311 Mansion St, Cape May, NJ 08204

19. Shamone BYOB in Cape May NJ

If you're looking for a great place to eat with friends, Shamone BYOB in Cape May, NJ, is the place to go. This upscale restaurant is located within a bustling mall and offers a multi-course tapas menu. The wait staff is friendly and helpful, and the food is delicious. You can even bring your beer, wine, or non-alcoholic drinks; there is no corkage fee for guests who bring their wine. This is a good option for families or groups of friends. 316 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204

20. Tisha's Fine Dining in Cape May, NJ

Tisha's Fine Dining in CapeMay, NJ, is a quaint sit-down eatery that offers modern New American fare. Guests can bring their beer or wine and enjoy their meals on the patio. The restaurant is also open for lunch, serving sandwiches and burgers. You'll find a great meal here with a large group or just two friends. So, during your visit to Tisha's, remember to bring your bottle of wine or beer. 322 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204

21. Cape May Fish Market

The comfy joint features a raw bar, surf 'n' turf entrees, sandwiches & burgersandus and outside tables. A Cape May seafood restaurant must-try! No trip to Cape May would be complete without visiting this charming establishment. You'll be thrilled by the fresh, well-seasoned Seafood at Cape May's fish market. 408 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204

22. Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls

If you love seafood, you'll want to visit Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls in Cape May, NJ. This famous chain of seafood restaurants is located in six locations, including Wildwood, Sea Isle City, Ocean City, and Long Beach Island. While there, order the famous classic lobster roll and try the Chicken Strips. Both will make your next trip to Cape May, NJ, memorable. Its menu features Maine and Connecticut-style lobster rolls served with various condiments. The lobster roll is the most popular appetizer with butter and mayo. The restaurant is also home to an outdoor dining area with beautiful views of Cape May Beach. 709 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204

23. Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar

This restaurant is known for its fresh seafood, steak, and pub & grill fare. It also has a full bar and is a great place to try local wines and craft beers. The restaurant is located on Lafayette Street, opposite the Acme. It's off the beaten path, so you'll find a mix of locals and tourists at the restaurant. While you're there, don't forget to order some homemade desserts. They have a great selection of desserts to round out your meal. You'll be glad you did! 615 Lafayette St, Cape May, NJ 08204

24. H&H Seafood Market

If you're looking for a seafood market in Cape May, NJ, you've come to the right place. H&H Seafood Market is a beautiful place to eat fresh, delicious seafood at an affordable price. This restaurant features a vast menu and is an excellent place for a family dinner. There are plenty of options for carryout, too, so you don't have to worry about dressing up for dinner. The menu includes fresh buckets of crab, lobster, and other options. 956 Ocean Dr, Cape May, NJ 08204

25. Brine

Brine is a waterfront restaurant in Cape May, New Jersey. Located on the waterfront at the South Jersey Marina, the Saltwater Cafe serves classic American breakfast and lunch dishes and innovative and creative menu items. The restaurant also offers delivery and accepts credit cards. Guests can order food on their way to the beach. 1231 NJ-109, Cape May, NJ 08204

Getting There

Group transportation can significantly enhance the restaurant dining experience, making it not just about the food but also the journey. Furthermore, group transportation alleviates the stress of driving and parking, and it can also be a responsible choice for evenings where drinks may be involved. Ultimately, group transportation creates a collective memory, turning a simple restaurant outing into a memorable event

Joy Franklin
Food and Event Writer
My joy is aimed at food and foodie lovers. I enjoy covering trends, issues, and all things Philly.


Latest Posts

Sign up via our free email subscription service to receive notifications when new information is available.

Sponsered Ads

Follow PhillyBite:

Follow Our Socials Below