The Lehigh Valley, a dynamic region encompassing Allentown, Bethlehem, and Easton, Pennsylvania, is a melting pot of cultures, history, and, most importantly, incredible food. While known for its industrial heritage and scenic beauty, the Valley has also quietly cultivated a thriving Pizza scene, offering everything from time-honored Italian-American traditions to modern, innovative creations.
From Crispy Crusts to Gourmet Toppings: The 5 Best Pizza Shops in the Lehigh Valley, PA
Finding the "best" Pizza is a deliciously subjective quest that sparks fervent debates among locals. However, based on consistent quality, enduring popularity, and that undefinable "something special," here are five standout Pizza shops that consistently earn top marks in the Lehigh Valley.
1. Sal's Pizza (Allentown & Bethlehem)
Why it's a must-try: A true Lehigh Valley institution, Sal's Pizza has been serving up classic New York-style pies for decades, earning a fiercely loyal following. Their secret lies in the perfect trifecta: a thin, crispy-chewy crust that holds up to every topping, a perfectly seasoned sauce that's neither too sweet nor too acidic, and a generous layer of high-quality, bubbly mozzarella. It's the quintessential slice that brings people back again and again.
Signature Slice: The classic Pepperoni, where the robust flavor of the meat perfectly complements its traditional base.
2. Lehigh Pizza (Allentown)
Why it's a must-try: Located in West Allentown, Lehigh Pizza is a local gem celebrated for its consistent quality and friendly service. They specialize in a slightly thicker, yet still perfectly crispy, traditional American-style Pizza. Their sauce is rich and savory, and they are known for loading on the fresh toppings. Whether you're craving a simple cheese pie or a fully loaded "Works" pie, Lehigh Pizza delivers a hearty, satisfying experience every time.
Signature Slice: The "Works" Pizza, piled high with fresh vegetables and meats.
3. Starters Pub (Bethlehem & Allentown)
Why it's a must-try: While primarily known as a sports bar and pub, Starters consistently surprises patrons with its unexpectedly fantastic Pizza. Their thin-crust, brick-oven pizzas are renowned for their perfectly crisp texture and inventive topping combinations. It's a great spot to catch a game and enjoy a gourmet-quality pie that goes beyond typical pub fare. Their commitment to fresh ingredients and a perfectly cooked crust sets them apart.
Signature Slice: Try their unique "Pierogi Pizza" or the "Buffalo Chicken" for a flavorful twist.
4. Bruno's Pizza & Restaurant (Easton)
Why it's a must-try: A beloved fixture in Easton, Bruno's has been serving authentic Italian-American cuisine, with Pizza as a definite highlight, for many years. Their traditional pizzas feature a well-balanced sauce and cheese on a solid, flavorful crust. Beyond their standard round pies, their Sicilian is a true standout – thick, airy, and with a wonderfully crispy base that's incredibly satisfying without being overly heavy.
Signature Slice: The Sicilian Pizza —a hearty, delicious square.
5. Louie's Restaurant (Allentown)
Why it's a must-try: Louie's is an Allentown institution that has stood the test of time, drawing crowds with its classic Italian fare and, of course, its Pizza. Their pies are known for a slightly sweeter sauce and a robust, chewy crust that evokes a nostalgic, old-school pizzeria feel. It's the kind of place where consistency reigns, and you know you'll get a reliably good, comforting slice every time.
Signature Slice: The classic cheese Pizza, perfect in its simplicity.
Honorable Mentions: The Lehigh Valley's Pizza landscape is vast and delicious! Other highly recommended spots include Pizza D'Oro (Allentown for unique combinations), Vincenzo's Pizzeria (Bethlehem for authentic Italian), and Two Rivers Brewing Company (Easton for craft beer and wood-fired Pizza).
So, whether you're a local on a quest for your new favorite or a visitor eager to taste the Valley's best, these Pizza shops offer a delicious journey through the Lehigh Valley's vibrant culinary heart. Grab a slice —or a whole pie —and savor the flavor!
Share Lehigh Valley Pizza on Social Media
Written By: Philly Bite Magazines Staff
The Best Of Series consists of a round-up of the best places to find great food, entertainment, and more in Philly and the Burbs.
