Joseph Ritter: ‘People Don't Care How Much Until They Know How Much You Care’

Joseph Ritter has spent two decades perfecting something that could be considered unusual in the insurance industry: genuine human connection. While many insurance professionals measure success by sales volume, Ritter's approach centers on building relationships that extend far beyond initial transactions.

"I learn more from my clients than they learn from me," says Ritter, a top 1% financial professional recognized by the Million Dollar Round Table, a global organization comprised of life insurance and financial services professionals. In fact, he’s a member of the elite Top of the Table, reserved for those who show a premium production of $5 million in just one calendar year. To date, he’s built up a loyal client base of more than 2,500 individuals across his career.

Trust forms the cornerstone of any meaningful client relationship, and for Ritter, establishing that trust begins with demonstrating clear expertise. With 20 years in the Medicare and insurance industry, his experience allows him to navigate complexities that often overwhelm clients.

"I've only done this 3,000 times," Ritter notes with a smile. 

What truly sets him apart, however, is his position as an independent broker rather than a company-affiliated agent. "The agent that works for the company, their responsibility lies with the company that they work for," he explains. "Whereas my responsibility lies with my client or my future client exclusively."

This distinction represents more than just business structure — it establishes the foundation for all client interactions. By representing the client's interests rather than pushing specific insurance products, Ritter begins relationships with transparency and aligned incentives.

Joseph Ritter: ‘People Don't Care How Much Until They Know How Much You Care’

Ritter’s philosophy permeates every aspect of client approach. He insists, “People don’t care how much until they know how much you care.”  Rather than overwhelming prospects with complex options or technical jargon, he focuses first on understanding their specific situations.

"I use my decades of experience to ask them questions and do what they call needs-based selling," Joseph Ritter explains. "I'm finding out as much as I can about this individual so that I can make sure they find the right coverage."

This personalized tactic continues throughout the relationship. Unlike some professionals who disappear after the initial sale, Ritter maintains consistent contact with clients.

"I don't want to just sell them a plan and then be talking to their friend and be like, 'Well, why does my friend have benefits that I don't have?'" he says. "I want to do an annual review with these people and make sure that as things change, we're continuously optimizing and making sure they're getting everything that they paid for."

The Client Journey: From First Meeting to Lifelong Relationship

Ritter's relationship-building process begins before he even meets prospective clients, thoroughly researching their backgrounds when possible. "You want to be prepared, you want to be on time. You want to do a little bit of research about the person you're meeting with," he advises. "It just shows that you care when you do that."

During initial meetings, he creates an environment where clients feel comfortable asking questions. By simplifying complex Medicare concepts into understandable language, he reduces anxiety and builds trust.

"At the end, people always say the same thing," Ritter notes. "They're like, 'That's it? What else do I need to do? It can't possibly be that easy.'"

This clarity extends to setting expectations for the future. Ritter proactively addresses potential issues clients might encounter, from paperwork they'll receive to changes in coverage they might experience.

"I'm going to preemptively tell them this is going to happen, and then that's going to happen," he explains. "When it happens, they're not worried or concerned because they're like, 'Oh, Joe told me this was going to happen.'"

Learning From Clients: A Two-Way Street

Perhaps most distinctive about Joseph Ritter's method is his genuine belief that client relationships benefit him as much as they do his clients.

"These people are doctors, lawyers, business owners, entrepreneurs, investors," he notes. "Just like they're getting a lot of value and information from me about what I'm specifically there to help them with, I'm getting information and ideas and building relationships with them simultaneously."

This mutual exchange creates deeper connections than typical professional relationships. "These are people that I consider like family," Ritter emphasizes. "I could call them if I had a question about something, and I knew they were the expert in it. Why can't we help one another?"

Ritter's commitment to personal connection extends beyond official meetings. He travels to meet clients face-to-face, even when it's not strictly necessary for business purposes.

"I'm in Arizona with a friend that I met five years ago," he shares. "He's turning 65, he's going on Medicare. He knows what I do. I flew out to the West Coast just to spend time with him. That was my primary objective, but also help him find the right plan based on what I know about him."

These personal investments of time strengthen relationships in ways that digital communications cannot. "In about an hour, I'm going to go meet with another client in Phoenix that's referred me to dozens of people and we've never met in person, so I'm going to take him out to lunch."

The meetup centers around a relationship-first mindset: "I'm not looking to get anything out of it, but I bet you I will because he will remember that, and now he's going to continue to tell people about me."

Scaling Without Losing the Personal Touch

Maintaining personal connections with thousands of clients presents a significant challenge as Joseph Ritter's business grows. He candidly acknowledges this tension. "Joe Ritter is a service. People don't want me to pass them off to someone else that's less qualified when they want to work with me, but I've already got 3,000 clients. How do you scale that?"

Rather than pursuing growth at all costs, he focuses on optimizing his client mix. "Maybe instead of selling a hundred Medicare plans, I sell 50 Medicare plans and I do annuities and retirement planning and life insurance, some of the more high-ticket type offers. That way I can optimize my work-life schedule."

This selective approach allows him to maintain quality relationships while still growing his business. "There could be a way to scale back service work and scale revenue and opportunities," he explains.

Traditional success metrics like revenue or client numbers tell only part of Joseph Ritter's story. For him, the true measure of achievement lies in the strength and longevity of client relationships.

"People always ask me, ‘What's the best investment?’" he says. "‘What's the cryptocurrency that you're hot on right now, or the best stock?’ I think the best investment is building relationships with the right people."

His perspective extends beyond financial returns. "Spending your time with people that make you happy," he suggests, provides a better return than any market investment.

This relationship-centered definition of success manifests in client loyalty and referrals — the lifeblood of his business. Satisfied clients naturally share their positive experiences with friends and family, creating organic growth without aggressive marketing tactics.

Share This Article on Social Media