Top 10 Best Grilled Cheese Spots in Pennsylvania

Grilled Cheese, has been a staple in American households, college dorm rooms, and cozy diners

Top 10 Best Grilled Cheese Spots in Pennsylvania

  • Smaller Small Medium Big Bigger
  • Default Helvetica Segoe Georgia Times

Grilled CheesePennsylvania - No matter how you slice it, grilled cheese has been a staple in American households, college dorm rooms, and cozy diners since the first bowl of tomato soup felt lonely.

Who Has The Best Grilled Cheese in PA?

There is absolutely nothing quite like an ooey-gooey grilled cheese sandwich. Our staff has picked the following PA restaurants and bars that offer up some of Pennsylvania's best-grilled cheese sandwiches, holding absolutely nothing back when it comes to melted, cheesy deliciousness and decadence.

Red Skillet - Wellsboro, PA

Specializing in local craft beer, ciders, seltzers, and more. But don't forget about trying the Grilled Cheese. The must-try is the Gourmet Grilled Cheese – Made with Local Potter County Havarti cheese melted with tomato and basil pesto on our grilled focaccia, on the lunch menu. Located at 102 PA-287, Wellsboro, PA

Railroad Street Bar and Grill - Linfield, PA

Draft microbrews, gourmet burgers, and pub fare are served in a convivial setting with pinball games. Must-try here is The Government Grilled Cheese – It's made with three kinds of cheese American, cheddar, and provolone. Located at 36 Railroad St, Linfield, PA

Good Dog Bar - Philadelphia, PA

Hip bar serving craft beer and signature blue-cheese burgers on 3 pooch-themed floors. Must-try is the mustard-braised barroom grilled cheese brisket, with Emmenthaler cheese on pieces of sourdough bread with hand-cut fries. 224 South 15th Street, Philadelphia PA

The Abbey on Butler Street - Pittsburgh, PA

Trendy, spacious cafe serving espresso, craft beer, and cocktails, plus New American cuisine. Try the Pimento Cheese Melt - With pimento cheese spread, Pittsburgh dill pickles on a house sourdough bread. Located at 4635 Butler St, Pittsburgh, PA

Say Cheese! Restaurant and Cheese - West Reading, PA

This artisanal cheese shop and elevated eatery is preparing American comfort food with a modern twist. Must-try is the Bacon and Tomato Grilled Cheese - With cheddar, brioche bread, skin-on fries w/malt vinegar mayo. Located at 600 Penn Ave, West Reading, PA

Mac Mart - Philadelphia PA

Mac 'n' cheese is the base of this fast-casual bowl concept with comfort food-inspired toppings. Classic Mac sandwiched between two buttery slices of Texas Toast, melted American Cheese and grilled to perfection. 104 South 18th Street, Philadelphia PA

Bier's Pub and War Streets Brewery - Pittsburgh, PA

Two barrels are used to make beers on-site at this casual, wood-filled bar with an American menu. Must-try is the Loaded Grilled Cheese – with sharp cheddar, bacon, grilled poblano peppers, onions, and tomatoes. Located at 900 Western Ave, Pittsburgh, PA

Gracie's On West Main - Leola, PA

Comfy neighborhood spot featuring homestyle American fare with a twist, along with espresso drinks. The must-try here is the Double Bacon Egg and Cheese Grilled Cheese – Grilled sourdough with American and Cheddar cheese, double smoked bacon, and Irish bacon with two eggs. Located at 264 W Main St, Leola, PA

Prophet's Melt Shop - Altoona, PA

This small melt shop is serving up unique grilled cheese combinations in Western PA. Try the Co-Jack – Made with Pearl Valley Marbled Colby Jack Cheese on Buttered Sourdough. Pairs well with our Signature Tomato Bisque. Located at 1231 11th Ave, Altoona, PA

The Charcuterie - Stroudsburg, PA

An excellent site for cured meats and cheeses, sandwiches and gastropub fare, plus wines and classic cocktails. The must-try here is the Brie Grilled Cheese – A double cream brie, granny smith apples, fig jam on a twelve-grain bread. Located at 548 Main St, Stroudsburg, PA

Readers Additions:

WHEEL Pottsville - Pottsville, PA

A Grilled Cheese Restaurant with 75 different ingredients to be added to your personal customized grilled cheese. Located at 201 W Market St in Pottsville, PA, and one in Tamaqua, PA.

PhillyBite Magazines Best Lists

How do we choose who is the best? PhillyBite's Best of Philly and regional lists are based on suggestions from our readers and our staff's deep knowledge of the region's deep cultural history. If you find any errors or have a suggestion of your own. Email us at: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Share PA Grilled Cheese on Social Media


Written By: Philly Bite Magazines Staff

Pennsylvania's Best Of Series consists of a round-up of the best places to find great food, entertainment, and more in PA.

Best Pennsylvania Grilled Cheese


Latest Posts

Sign up via our free email subscription service to receive notifications when new information is available.

Sponsered Ads

Follow PhillyBite:

Follow Our Socials Below