Where to Find The Best Cumberland County PA Pizza

Where to Find The Best Cumberland County PA Pizza

Photo: Brads Pizza

  • Smaller Small Medium Big Bigger
  • Default Helvetica Segoe Georgia Times

Cumberland County, PennsylvaniaPennsylvania - Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, has several great pizza joints with just about every type of pizza you can imagine; and it's not hard to find more than one place to fall in love with. Like a Brad's Pizza in Carlisle serving up a stuffed meat pizza or Giuseppe's Pizza Cantina's New York-Style pizza with its big thick crust. Listed below are a few of our staffs-picks for Where to Find The Best Pizza Shops and Restaurants in Cumberland County, PA.



Best Pizza in Carlisle and Cumberland County

Brad's Pizza

One of the Best pizza shops on the West Shore, they make a great stuffed meat pizza. It's basically two pizzas mashed together and well worth the wait. It will feed a family of four people easily. One tip is to order in advance. It does take a while to make. 1548 Spring Rd, Carlisle, PA

Napoli Pizza

Napoli has been the best-tasting Pizza in Carlisle. It has a perfectly crisp, chewy crust, with an incredible garlic flavor marinara sauce topped off with fresh mozzarella cheese. Just one bite and we were hooked on the "Napoli Pizza," topped off with fresh basil leaves. This pie has the perfect crust and quality toppings with a tangy Pizza sauce that makes Napoli Pizza one of the best in the county.1075 Harrisburg Pike #111, Carlisle, PA

Giuseppe's Pizza Cantina

New York-style pizza fresh out of the oven. With a nice and thin crust with the perfect crisp on the bottom and the right cheese to sauce ratio. The super think crust stands out on this pie, and prices are reasonable for the area. 600 E Simpson St, Mechanicsburg, PA

The Pizza Shop Enola

A family-run shop that makes a Sicilian supreme that is fantastic, with a great crust to pizza ratio. Everything comes out fresh and delicious from the dough to the toppings—a must-try for anyone who loves Pizza. You can't go wrong with the Pizza here. 299 W Shady Ln, Enola, PA

Villa Roma Pizza & Subs

New York-style Pizza in New Cumberland and one of the best NY-Style pizzas in the area. The crust is crispy, the sauce tastes well crust, not too greasy and not too dry, and it's evident that all the ingredients are fresh. 314 Market St, New Cumberland, PA

Share Carlisle and Cumberland County Pizza on Social Media


Written By: Philly Bite Magazines Staff

The Best Of  Pizza Series consists of a round-up of the best places to find great food, entertainment, and more in Philly and Beyond.

Carlisle and Cumberland County Pizza Restaurants and Shops


Latest Posts

Sign up via our free email subscription service to receive notifications when new information is available.

Sponsered Ads

Follow PhillyBite:

Follow Our Socials Below